I found some more ideas for neighbor gifts here that don't take much to put together...
M&M's:
"Have a Merry and Most wonderful Holiday Season!"
Soup or soup mix:
"Wishing you a souper Holiday Season!!"
Frozen or ready to bake pizza:
"Warm up to a wonderful Holiday Season topped with Christmas cheer!"
Popcorn Balls:
"Hoping you have a ball this Holiday Season!"
Loaf of Bread:
For being there when you were kneaded,
for rising to the occasion, large or small,
for never loafing on the job,
no matter how you slice it,
you do a terrific job of loving others
Merry Christmas!!
Jolly Ranchers:
Have a Holly Jolly Christmas!!
Rootbeer:
We're rooting for you to have a Happy Holiday Season and a Wonderful New Year!
Chex Party Mix:
Remember Santa chex his list twice to see who's been naughty or nice,
so be good for goodness sake!! Merry Christmas!!
Box of Hostess Ho-Ho's:
Ho - Ho - Hoping your Christmas is Heavenly
Wire Wisk (Filled with Chocolate kisses):
We WHISK you a Merry KISSmas!
Christmas Tray:
We tray-sure your friendship! Merry Christmas!!
Potpourri:
May this sweet scent bring back thoughts of warm Christmases long ago! Merry Christmas!
Household Cleaners:
You add sparkle and make our life brighter! Merry Christmas!
Broom:
You're dust the finest neighbors we know! Merry Christmas!
Paper Towels:
Absorb the Christmas Spirit!
Measuring Cup or Glass Measure:
Wishing you Joy Beyond Measure!
Chocolate Mousse Mix:
Merry Christmousse
Cinnamon Sprinkles (Cinnamon & Sugar, or cookie sprinkles):
May your Christmas be sprinkled with laughter and love! Merry Christmas!
Salsa:
Add a little spice to your Holidays! Merry Christmas!
Holly:
Happy Hollydays!
Calendar:
Keep Christmas in your heart the whole year through!
Sparkling Cider:
Wishing you a sparkling Holiday Season!
Popcorn or Carmel Corn:
Just popping by with a Holiday Hi!
Fruit Basket:
May your New Year be Festive and Fruitful!
Any Sweet Treat:
Wishing you a season filled with sweetness!
Oranges:
Orange you glad we're Friends? Merry Christmas!
Chocolate Orange:
Orange you glad it's Christmas? Hope your Christmas is a sweet one!
Sprite:
May your Christmas be Merry and Sprite!
Snicker Bar:
Don't Snicker, just be glad you got something!
Matches:
No one matches you as neighbors! Merry Christmas!
Strainer:
We couldn't restrain ourselves from wishing you a very Merry Christmas!
Box of Light Bulbs:
Have a bright and radiant Christmas
Bubble Gum or Bubble Bath:
May your holidays bubble over with fun!
Pencil and Notepad:
Merry Christmas from our pad to yours!
or
Merry Christmas to a noteworthy friend!
Grater and Cheese:
To a grate Neighbor! Merry Christmas!"
Ice Cream:
Have a cool Yule!
Eggnog:
Have an udderly moovalous Christmas!
Muffins or Muffin mix:
We wanted to give you something so you weren't getting muffin for Christmas!
Christmas Shaped pasta (Or any Pasta and a bottle of Sauce):
Have a Pasta-tively Happy Holiday!
Brownie Mix (Or any Mix):
Whip up this mix for a wonderful holiday fix!
Pie:
Just a Holiday Hi and a tasty Pie! Happy Holidays!
Fudge:
Fudge a little on the calories and enjoy the Holiday Season!
Banana Bread:
Banana Bread just for you, because you have so much to do.
We love you a whole bunch! Merry Christmas!"
Cinnamon Rolls:
Here's a sweet treat rolled up with warm Holiday Wishes! Merry Christmas!
Recipe:
Just like you, friend it's tried and true, just for you! Happy Holiday Baking or Merry Christmas Cooking!
Pizza:
Hope your Holiday has a touch of Pizza - z! Merry Christmas!
P.S. Don't forget that you can add a personal note to make it meaningful.